Law Society of WA

The tale of the famous button seller

November 20, 2026

By John McKechnie AO, KC

There once lived a man who seemed to make a living selling buttons at shows because there was good dough in it.

But the forces of law and order suspected all was not as it appeared.

The button seller was well dressed and respectful and seemed to have money sufficient for his needs.

However, it was his companions who caught the eyes of the authorities. They were fellow showmen whom he met in public places by day.

Now it may seem hard to believe but less than 80 years ago, certain behaviour could lead to a person being deemed an idle and disorderly person, a rogue and vagabond, or worst of all, an incorrigible rogue.

Moreover, the law had provisions for preventative justice. A person threatening to commit a breach of the peace was required to give sureties as was a person found to be of evil fame.

The authorities argued that the button seller was a person of evil fame because of his association with convicted and suspected persons.

So it was that one fine day, the button seller appeared before FEA (Alan) Bateman, resident Magistrate. The Magistrate found the charge proved and ordered the button seller to provide sureties.

Thus, the button seller who until that day, was merely a seller of wares at sideshows became famous in an evil sort of way.

Resisting the urge to simply “button it up”, he decided to appeal to the Full Court.

The leading judgment was given by Mr Justice Virtue. What a marvellous name for a Judge. Until I became a law student, I thought that Justice was his given name and he was a man who combined not one, but two excellent moral qualities.

The Judge noted that police had the button seller under observation for six months and on no occasion, had he done anything wrong.

All that the police had seen was that the button seller frequented hotel bars, billiard saloons, at country and district shows and in the daytime, was sometimes seen in the company of convicted or suspicious persons.

The learned Judge had trouble with the meaning of ‘evil fame’. It was not found in standard or legal dictionaries as a phrase of specialised meaning and were not words in common use.

 The Judge went back in time to the reign of Edward III for assistance.

Skipping a few centuries, Sir John (as he later became) then enlisted that trusty helpmate, William Blackstone:

… it is held that a man may be bound to his good behaviour for causes of scandal, contra bonos mores, as well as contra pacem … Thus also a justice may bind over all night-walkers; eavesdroppers; such as keep suspicious company, or are reported to be pilferers or robbers; such as sleep in the day and wake in the night; common drunkards; whore-masters; cheats; idle vagabonds; and other persons whose misbehaviour may reasonably bring them within the general words of the statute, as persons not of good fame; an expression, it must be owned, of so great a latitude, as leaves much to be determined by the discretion of the magistrate himself.

If those who sleep in the day and wake in the night were targeted for strong police action, scarcely a university student would be safe.

The Full Court held that the evidence fell far short of establishing that the button seller was famous, let alone infamous. If this evidence was the best they could do, the Full Court effectively told the police to “zip it”.

And so the button seller continued his itinerant life hawking his wares throughout the South West and presumably, playing billiards and talking to whomever he pleased.

(Adapted from Doyle v Jones (1952) 54 WALR 1)

Previous Story

WA moves to modernise defamation laws