Law Society of WA

Independent solicitor’s certificates: Getting the advice right

November 16, 2026

By the Commercial Law Committee of the Law Society of Western Australia

Australian courts have held that loans, security interests or guarantees may be set aside where a financier’s conduct is found to be unconscionable or the transaction is entered into by a borrower/guarantor under duress or undue influence from another party. 

What is the issue?

There is a material risk that a transaction could be set aside due to unconscionable conduct by the financier where a borrower or guarantor has a ‘special disadvantage’.  A special disadvantage has been described by the High Court as something that seriously affects a person’s ability to make a judgement as to their own best interests (Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447 at 462).  A special disadvantage can arise from a number of factors, including from poverty or need, sickness, age, gender, injury or illness (including mental illness), intoxication, illiteracy or lack of education or lack of assistance or explanation where assistance or explanation is necessary (Blomley v Ryan (1956) 99 CLR 362 at 405).

If a borrower or guarantor has a special disadvantage and the financier has a superior position or bargaining power, has knowledge of the borrower’s or guarantor’s special disadvantage and unconscientiously exploits that special disadvantage, the financier’s action is likely to constitute unconscionable conduct and the relevant loan, security interest or guarantee is liable to be set aside.

Providing evidence that a borrower or guarantor has obtained legal advice can form part of a defence for a financier should proceedings be brought.  For this reason financiers commonly require evidence of legal advice having been obtained as a condition precedent to a financing transaction.

What is the risk?

The usual role of a solicitor in a commercial transaction is to advise a client in relation to legal risks and documentation.  Having taken the solicitor’s advice, the client will then make a decision on whether or not to transact.  In these circumstances, the solicitor’s duty (and liability) is to their own client.  The solicitor does not ordinarily have a direct duty to other parties to the transaction.

However, where a solicitor gives confirmations or direct statements to another party the solicitor may incur duties (and liabilities) to that other non-client party.  This can be the case where a solicitor issues an independent legal advice certificate or declaration to a financier confirming that the borrower or guarantor for whom the solicitor acts has received legal advice in connection with the relevant loan, security interest or guarantee. 

By issuing the certificate or declaration to the financier, the solicitor exposes themselves to direct risk should the transaction go wrong.

In addition, a solicitor would breach Rule 11 if they fail to follow the requirements set out in that rule. 

How should the risk be managed?

Assess competence

The starting point for any solicitor is to determine that they are competent to provide the required advice.  This should be considered carefully, as generalist practitioners or non-finance specialists may be asked to issue a certificate on short notice by a client trying to meet an urgent financing deadline. 

Laws relating to loans, security interests and guarantees are complex and important issues may be overlooked where a solicitor who is not familiar with these issues reviews standard form finance documentation.  Such documentation, when prepared by a sophisticated financier, will often contain extensive provisions purporting to set aside certain general law rights that a borrower, security provider or guarantor may have.  Properly advised clients should be made aware of these matters as part of the advice given to them.

Further, a solicitor should only agree to advise a client and issue a certificate if they have time to review the transaction documents and are free from conflicts.  In respect of conflicts, the starting point is that solicitors should not act for multiple parties to a transaction as they would not be truly independent. 

For this reason, a borrower and a guarantor may need to engage separate solicitors for the same transaction.  Particular care should be taken when assessing conflicts where the borrowers and/or guarantors are members of the same family (for example).

If the solicitor decides to accept the instruction and proceed, the requirements of Rule 11 should be strictly followed.  Rule 11 is prescriptive and offers little discretion for solicitors.  The requirements cover verification of identity, the use of prescribed forms to evidence the solicitor’s advice, the role of interpreters or translators (where relevant) and the forms of acknowledgement of advice that should be obtained from clients, together with filing requirements.

Verification of identity

Rule 11.2 requires solicitors to verify the identity of the proposed signatory of the relevant loan, security interest or guarantee using the Verification of Identity Standard contained in Schedule 8 to the Model Participation Rules determined by the Australian Registrar’s National Electronic Conveyancing Council as adopted and made by each jurisdiction pursuant to section 23 of the Electronic Conveyancing National Law. 

In Western Australia, version 7 of the WA Participation Rules (WAPRs) currently applies.  The Verification of Identity Standard is set out in Schedule 8 and states in paragraph 2.1 that verification of identity must be carried out in person.  While Rule 6.5.2 of the WAPRs provides for verification of identity using the Verification of Identity Standard or verification in some other way that constitutes the taking of reasonable steps, best practice for WA solicitors is to verify identity in a face to face in person meeting.

Use of proscribed forms

Rule 11 contemplates the use of either the proscribed forms issued by the Law Society of New South Wales or the Law Institute of Victoria.  Rule 11.3 expressly requires solicitors to use either of these forms.  Using any other form would constitute a breach.

While there is no express reference to Western Australian forms, the Legal Practice Board of Western Australia has, following request for clarification from Law Mutual, confirmed that Rule 11 does apply to Western Australian solicitors.  Law Mutual issued a risk alert on 26 June 2026 highlighting this and stating its view that Western Australian solicitors should use the New South Wales form, since the Law Society of New South Wales has updated its forms to contemplate Western Australian specific items (whereas the Law Institute of Victoria has not).

Practitioners should also note that the New South Wales form is structured as a statutory declaration made by the client who has been advised by the solicitor, with the solicitor only giving a confirmation in respect of the verification of identity aspects.  The Victorian form is structured as a certificate issued directly to a financier with the solicitor making certain proscribed statements.  From a solicitor’s risk perspective, the New South Wales approach is also preferred for this reason.

Translation/interpretation

Solicitors should be careful to assess the English language proficiency of their clients.  If a solicitor has any concerns about whether the client is capable of clearly understanding the documentation and advice in English, they should arrange for a translator or interpreter to attend the meeting at which the advice is given. 

Rule 11.5 requires the name of the interpreter or translator to be included on the applicable certificate and for the interpreter or translator to complete a certification in the proscribed form.  Western Australian solicitors should use the New South Wales form, being the Law Society of NSW Interpreter’s Certificate Schedule 3 to ensure consistency with other New South Wales form being used.

Client acknowledgement and file requirements

Solicitors should follow up any oral advice given at the in-person meeting with prompt written confirmation of the advice.  This should be retained on the solicitor’s files.  In addition, Rule 11.6 obliges solicitors to obtain acknowledgements from their clients in the proscribed forms.  The applicable New South Wales forms are the Law Society of NSW Acknowledgement of Legal Advice Schedule 4, 4A, 4B or 4C. 

Again, these forms should be used (rather than the Victorian equivalents) to ensure consistency with the use of other New South Wales forms.  It is important to note that the New South Wales forms of acknowledgement should not be provided to the financier, as they operate as an acknowledgement of advice between the client and solicitor.  Providing the acknowledgement to a third party (such as a financier) may give rise to claims for waiver of privilege and may have other consequences in connection with a solicitor’s duty of confidentiality.

In addition to the proscribed form acknowledgements, solicitors are required under Rule 11.6 to retain a copy of the issued certificate, a copy of the translator’s or interpreter’s certificate and a list of the relevant loan and security documents.  Best practice would be to retain full form copies of all relevant documents notwithstanding the rules only require a list of the documents to be retained.

Duties of other solicitors

Rule 11.8 states that solicitors (e.g. a solicitor acting for a lender) must not aid, abet, counsel or procure any other solicitor to provide evidence of legal advice otherwise than in conformity with Rule 11.  It is important that solicitors acting on a transaction for other parties are aware of this rule and act in a manner consistent with it.  Failure to do so would be a breach of the rules.

The specific New South Wales forms that should be used are:

FormWhen used
Law Society of NSW Declaration by Borrower/Grantor of a Security Interest – Schedule 1A natural person who is a borrower is granting a security interest
Law Society of NSW Declaration by Borrower/Guarantor of a Security Interest – Schedule 1AA corporation that is a borrower is granting a security interest
Law Society of NSW Declaration by Borrower/Guarantor of a Security Interest – Schedule 1BA trustee of a trust that is a borrower is granting a security interest
Law Society of NSW Declaration by Third Party Mortgagor, Guarantor, Surety Mortgagee or Indemnifier for the Borrower/Grantor of a Security Interest – Schedule 2 

Key points summary

  1. It has become common practice for lenders and other financiers to require borrower and guarantors to obtain independent legal advice before entering into formal documentation for loan and other financing transactions. 
  • It is also now common for solicitors to be asked to provide a certification or declaration to the financier that evidences the advice. 
  • Issuing a certificate or declaration of this type to a financier has the potential to expose the solicitor to direct claims from the financier if a transaction goes wrong. 
  • Rule 11 of the Legal Profession Uniform Legal Practice (Solicitors) Rules 2015 (Rule 11) regulates how solicitors should deal with these matters.
  • Best practice for a Western Australian solicitor is to use the forms specified by the Law Society of New South Wales.
  • The Law Society of New South Wales has issued revised versions of its forms with amendments/drafting optionality for use by Western Australian solicitors.
  • Practitioners should treat these matters with high levels of care and caution given the risk of liability, including the risk of direct action by financiers against the solicitor.
Previous Story

Have we outdone ourselves? The paradox of forensic DNA sensitivity

Next Story

WA Young Lawyers Committee wins national award for engagement campaign